I am going to look at this objectively not really having an emotional attachment to either race.
Skar tanks Dire Lord and Warrior plus one off tank in monk vs Elf Warrior +1.5 for Skar.
Elf healers Druid, Shaman vs Skar Shaman +1 Elf.
Skar melee dps Rogue and monk vs Elf dps Ranger and Rogue a wash.
Elf magical dps Summoner and Wizard +2 Elf
Elf crowd control Enchanter +1 Elf
Skar have necromancer which probably will be magical dps and Elves have bards probably dps with crowd control will call that a wash for now.
Much easier to make a balanced war party for Elves...Elves win in a landslide can build a balanced war party!
Elves have a longer lifespan and with the magical abilities- survive longer and retain tactics and wisdom to allow them to survive the longer lifespan so Elves don't die easy.
But Skar have such a "survival of the fittest" thing going that through constant winnowing and culling the herd that their genetic make-up must be so brutally refined to make them resilient to alot of things, making them really hard to kill.
Elves don't die easy, Skar are hard to kill. Hard to pick one!.
Kilsin said:Pantheon Race Battles - Round 3 - FIGHT - Elves vs Skar, who wins and why? #PRF #MMORPG #MMO #communitymatters
I think you're asking the wrong question. It isn't about who wins, it is about who loses..and all of Terminus loses because while we all believe the Skar and Elves hate each other there are plenty of examples throughout various myths, stories and tales where two races who apparently hated each other would invariably end up with one pair falling in love. That love would spread and eventually the races would realize the folly of their hatred and peace would then reign. And what nobody in Terminus wants are disgusting Skar/Elf hybrid babies all over the damn place.
Skars have skar tissue , which gives nice natural armor boost and a cool RHCP song to bolster the morale in battle.
what do the elves have?
Elveted ground? (prequel memes intensifies...)
elf cosmetics on their face?
E.l.f tires on their chariots?
Elves are doomed in this battle.
Elves... Hard to hit.. what you cant touch. Be it rangers or wizards from afar. Throw in the realtionship of elves with nature and its surroundings...Many skar would be picked off before a chance to retaliate effectively. Close in... skar would benefit from ruthless behavior but can be countered with the crowd control of the enc. Hard to be slowed and mezzed and still maintain a bull rush..
Me personally regardless of odds would be skar simply for the direlord. Dying is not an issue for me.. as long as I take some with me. It is not about my survival it is about my ability to kill and give glory to those who survive past me. Not really it would still be about my desire to spill blood. Poor elves value life.. and are weak for it.
We have to be honest here. Those elves are pretty close to immortal - which makes them REALLy old and therefore their meat is stringy and gristly at best. As for the Skar, they are constantly warring with one race or another (and as often as not, themselves) and therefore their meat is often scarred and hard to chew. CLEARLY the only real winner here is YOU through the use of Hafling BBQ sauce.